In the culinary world, butter and shortening are often used in making cakes, breads and other foods. While both have similar functions, there are fundamental differences that affect the texture, flavor, and end result of a dish. Here are the main differences between butter and shortening.
Related Post: Know the Difference between Butter, Margarine, Butter and Roombutter
The basic ingredients used in making butter and shortening are important differentiators. Butter is made from milk fat that is whipped to separate the solids from the liquid, while shortening is made from processed vegetable fats, usually derived from palm, soybean or canola oil.
Because the ingredients are different, it affects the fat content, butter contains about 80% minimum fat, with the rest being water and milk solids, while shortening contains 100% fat with no water content.
Furthermore, Peekay friends can tell the difference from the texture, because it contains water butter has a lighter and layered texture in pastries such as croissants, while shortening which only contains fat has a crisper and softer texture, especially in pastries and frosting.
What about the flavor and aroma of both? Butter has a richer flavor and a distinctive aroma that gives food a delicious taste, while shortening does not have a strong flavor, more neutral, so it is often used in recipes that require a non-dominant flavor.
Butter has a lower melting point of about 32-35°C, making it easier to melt at room temperature. Meanwhile, shortening has a higher melting point of around 40°C, making it more stable for cream making and cake decorating.
Related Post: Here are the main differences between salted and unsalted butter that you need to know
The choice between butter and shortening depends on the recipe needs and flavor preferences. If you want a richer flavor and layered texture, butter is the best choice. However, if you want stability, softer texture, and longer shelf life, shortening can be a better alternative. It's best to use as needed and balance your consumption to still get the best benefits from both.
As a solution to the need for quality raw materials, Prambanan Kencana provides a variety of products ranging from butter, margarine, to high-quality shortening to support your culinary creations. Find our best products and realize the perfect processed results!
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |